Custom Orders
All Orders Must Be Booked
2 Weeks in Advance
Custom order pricing will vary depending on the requests of the customer.
Our custom cakes start between $3-$5 per serving for buttercream icing and $6-$8 per serving for fondant-covered cakes. The final cost will depend on how the cake is decorated. (See pricing list below for base prices)
Gluten free adds $15 per 15 servings.
​
Specialty cake fillings will add $5-$10 to the order depending on cake size and filling request.
​
Custom cupcakes start at $3/each. Photo decal topper cupcakes are $4 each.
Custom color cake pops are $3 each. We do offer individual bag-and-ribbon-tying for cookies and cake pops for a fee of $3/dozen.
​
Decorated sugar cookies start at $3 each. Shortbread cookies dipped in chocolate are $1.50 each. Platter assortments will be priced depending on the cookies selected. If you would like your cookies assembled onto a platter and gift bagged, there is an additional $5 platter fee.
​
Photo decal cookies are $3.50 each, photo decal topper cupcakes are $4.25 each, and decals add $15 to cake order.
​
Orders booked within 7 business days prior to an event may be subject to a $25 rush fee.
​
Deliveries : We do not deliver.
Mini Cupcake Samples
We do not offer tastings, but we offer mini cupcake samples for $1 each, minimum order quantity of 6 per flavor, with a minimum of 48 hours notice.
​
Orders and cake designs will be completed via email but if you would like a sit-down consultation, there is a $30 non-refundable fee for a 30 minute consultation.
Base Cake Pricing*
(the final price is determined by the cake design/decorations)
Size
Round
6in
8in
​
10in
12in
​
Rectangle
9x13
9x13
11x15
12x18
Square
6in
8in
10in
12in
​
2 Tiered*
Start at:
​
​
3 Tiered
Start at:
*tiered cakes will only have 2 cake layers per tier.
Layers
-
2
3
2
3
2
3
2
3
-
1
2
2
2
-
2
2
2
2
​
-
​
​
​
-
​
​
Servings
-
10
15
15
22
30
45
​
-
15
30
45
60
-
10
15
30
45
25
45
75
55
90
Cost
-
$40
$50
$50
$60
$95
$155
$140
$205
-
$50
$95
$145
$185
-
$50
$60
$100
$145
​
$90
$160
$230
$225
$365
CUSTOM UPGRADES
​
•Adding a 3rd layer of cake will increase the cost by $10-$20 depending upon the servings.
This pricing applies to smooth or rosette buttercream icing cake.
•Ombre icings, multi-colored rosette rows, marble cake, and gluten-free
add $10 per 15 servings to the base price.
•Edible photo decals add $15 each.
•Fillings add $5/layer to the base price.
•Fondant decorations and custom design requests are priced separately.
Larger cakes are available and are priced according to design details.
•Vanilla buttercream is the standard filling we use between cake layers. For an additional charge, you can choose a filling upgrade from any of our available buttercream icing flavors here.
•We also offer fruit preserve fillings of seedless raspberry, strawberry, blueberry, or blackberry.
Upgraded buttercream fillings or preserves will add a $5 charge to your cake order per tier.
•Color drips add $10 to the base price; Metallic drips add $20
•The amount of flavors you can select for your cake is determined by the number of cake layers in your order. A single tier has 2 to 3 layers of cake and you can choose a different flavor for each layer.
Our everyday walk-in available classic cupcake menu will vary depending on the season and our daily baking schedule.
Custom cupcakes can be done in any of our flavors, just email us at mommymagiccakes@live.com to place an order.
